About this Event
805 21st Street NW, Washington DC 20052
This plenary panel will take up three core questions: 1. What do we know about the conservative Christian vote in the 2024 election? 2. What do we see emerging from the Christian nationalist networks that were involved in the 2020 election denialism and even in the January 6th Insurrection? 3. How do various strands of Christian nationalism relate and perhaps overlap?
The 2020 AP VoteCast survey found that 81% of White evangelical Protestant voters cast their ballot for Donald Trump, compared with 18% who voted for Joe Biden. Trump can reasonably expect the same high levels of support from conservative religious voters in 2024. Yet there are at this writing signs that conservative Christian voters are having second thoughts about Trump, despite his fulfilled promise to deliver a conservative majority to overturn Roe v. Wade. With the strong public backlash after the Supreme Court’s 2022 Dobbs decision, a backlash that was intensified by the 2024 Alabama Supreme Court decision that said that embryos held in a cryopreservation tank were legally equivalent to living children, the Trump campaign and Trump himself backpedaled and equivocated on abortion restrictions, leaving many Christians feeling abandoned by Trump, even if he has been “anointed by God.” Of course, some Christian conservatives expressed the same belief in 2016. What do we know about the voting patterns of Evangelicals in the 2024 elections? With the assistance of an early assessment of Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI) polling data, our panel will evaluate what happened on election night 2024.
Our second set of questions concerns Christian nationalists, or what one of our panelists has described as white Christian nationalists. In 2020, Christian nationalists, often associated with what some refer to as the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) and aligned neo-Charismatics non-denominational churches and ministry networks, took an active and even leadership role in the January 6th events, as the numerous flags and other symbols attest. With what is looking to be a close election in 2024, we can reasonably anticipate something similar happening after this election, if not another insurrection, at least similar revival fury as seen in the leadup to the 2020 election and January vote certification.
A third set of questions concerns the boundaries between far-right Christian nationalists and more mainstream Evangelicals, on the one hand, and the boundaries between Christian nationalists and other “post-liberal” proponents and the organizations that support them. We might point to Turning Point Faith, the Claremont Institute, and the Heritage Foundation, just to name a few examples. How do Christian nationalists such as Lance Wallnau fit with post-liberal intellectuals such as Notre Dame University’s Patrick Deneen, Harvard University’s Adrian Vermeule, and the Claremont Institute’s Michael Anton and John Eastman? Perhaps these are entirely different strains of ethno-religious political thought that happen to share a common aspiration of “returning” the United States to a once-Christian past. If we were to draw a Venn Diagram, how would these and other possible bodies of thought align?
This event will be introduced by Alyssa Ayres, Dean of the Elliott School of International Affairs at The George Washington University, and moderated by Michel Martin, host of Morning Edition on NPR. Its distinguished panelists are Samuel Perry, E.J. Dionne, Robert P. Jones, Kristin Kobes Du Mez, Jim Wallis, and Andrew Thompson.